| | Opponent |
| Date | Game Results | Site | UM Coach | Game Notes | Conference | Head Coach | Nickname |
| 1/6/1996 | W 78-58 | Home (MC) | John Calipari | Camby welcomes Dayton to A-10 with a 38 & 11 performance. | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 2/23/1997 | L 69-67 | Away | James “Bruiser” Flint | at UD Arena. Travieso 22 points, Norville 12, Basit 10 rebounds. | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 2/1/1998 | W 85-69 | Home (MC) | James “Bruiser” Flint | UM pushes win streak to 10. Ketner 33 points, Mack 14, Clarke 13. | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 1/28/1999 | W 59-57 (OT) | Away | James “Bruiser” Flint | at UD Arena. Mack game winner with 10 seconds left. Ketner 16 & 11, Mack 15, Kirkland 13. | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 1/20/2000 | L 57-52 | Home (MC) | James “Bruiser” Flint | Kirkland 15, Mack 14, Rhymer 11 & 9. | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 1/18/2001 | W 62-57 | Home (MC) | James “Bruiser” Flint | UM shoots 51% and out-rebounds Dayton. Rhymer 19 & 13, Rogers 16 (8-9 shooting). | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 2/6/2001 | L 89-76 | Away | James “Bruiser” Flint | at UD Arena. UM whistled for 27 fouls, leading to 32 Flyer points at the line. Brand & Mack 23 each. | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 1/29/2002 | L 83-68 | Home (MC) | Steve Lappas | Dayton shoots 59% to UM's 36%. Crooks 21, Anderson 20. | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 1/29/2003 | L 83-55 | Away | Steve Lappas | at UD Arena. Dayton goes 26-30 from the line, UM 7-15. Lee 12 & 9, Anderson 10. | Atlantic 10 | Oliver Purnell | Flyers |
| 2/8/2004 | L 66-59 | Home (MC) | Steve Lappas | UM starters shoot 11-46 (24%). Lasme 13-7-6 off the bench, Chadwick 12. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 3/1/2005 | L 53-52 | Away | Steve Lappas | at UD Arena. Dayton benefits from questionable whistle at end. Carrier 11 & 8, Freeman 11, Maxwell 10. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 2/25/2006 | W 66-47 | Home (MC) | Travis Ford | Dayton shooting struggles: 37% FG, 35% FT. Life 25 points, Freeman 19 & 12. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 2/18/2007 | W 77-69 | Away | Travis Ford | at UD Arena. First Dayton home loss on season. Forbes 23 points, Freeman & Lasme double-doubles. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 1/16/2008 | W 82-71 | Away | Travis Ford | at UD Arena. First win over ranked team in 3 years. Harris 22 points, Lowe 19. Brower 11 & 9. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 1/10/2009 | W 76-65 | Home | Derek Kellogg | At the MassMutual Center, Springfield MA. UD was 14-1. 4 MMen in double-figures, led by Harris 23 points. Gaffney 7 blocks. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 2/27/2010 | L 96-68 | Away | Derek Kellogg | at UD Arena. Dayton hits 13 3s and shoots 55% overall. UM only hits 37%. Vinson 16 points. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 1/9/2011 | W 55-50 | Home (MC) | Derek Kellogg | UM scores 29 from stripe and 26 from field. UM wins rebounding 41-31 over what was top rebounding team in A-10. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 3/8/2011 | L 78-50 | Home (MC) | Derek Kellogg | Atlantic 10 Tournament First Round. UMass #8, Dayton #9. Seniors go out on awful note as Dayton dominates start to finish. | Atlantic 10 | Brian Gregory | Flyers |
| 2/25/2012 | L 76-43 | Away | Derek Kellogg | at UD Arena. UM goes ice cold: shoots 24.5% FG, 54.2% FT, gives up 36-9 run to end the game. Williams & Morgan combine for 3-23 shooting. | Atlantic 10 | Archie Miller | Flyers |
| 2/23/2013 | W 76-66 | Home (MC) | Derek Kellogg | Lalanne sets new career highs with his big effort. Vinson adds 13 & 6 in his 122nd start, first all time at UM. Chaz 9 assists builds his lead in conference stats. | Atlantic 10 | Archie Miller | Flyers |
